
Curtains is a new musical by famous writing duo Fred Ebb and John Kander, with an original book by Peter Stone, revised by Rupert Holmes, and under the direction of legend Scott Ellis. It stars David Hyde Pierce (in a Tony award winning role) as Boston police detective Frank Cioffi trying to solve a murder that happens on the set of a new musical having its pre-Broadway run. Everyone's a suspect and so the production is quarantined to the theatre. Cioffi has to crack the case while at the same time using his love of musical theatre to fix the show from the flop it currently is.
It's fun, if nothing else. Everything has shortcomings, but overall nothing is terrible enough to sink the show and stop it from being an over-the-top Broadway good time. Hyde Pierce is fantastic in an atypical lead role (atypical because everyone seems more like a featured player and he gets that status by default). The supporting cast of Karen Ziemba and Jason Daniely are good. But Debra Monk, as the show's producer, and Edward Hibbert, as the show's director, better embody the show's problems and strengths. They both get the brunt of delivering the majority of the show's one-liners, which range from great to terrible. While Hibbert makes all of them work with an absolutely hysterical performance, Monk isn't able to pull it off and turns in a very disappointing performance here. The direction is never bad but nothing leaps out either, making me remember Scott Ellis had anything to do with this. The only consistently impressive part of the entire show is Rob Ashford's choreography. I saw the show with two of my friends who know a great deal about dancing and they were as equally blown-away, mouths agape, as I was.
But the real reason to see Curtains has to do with death. Peter Stone (original book) died before finishing it. Rupert Holmes was brought into finish it. Then, in 2004, Fred Ebb himself died of a heart attack. Holmes helped John Kander finish the lyrics. It's only fitting that the story itself should be about people dying while trying to put up a musical. John Kander and Fred Ebb (Chicago, Cabaret, Kiss of the Spiderwoman) are icons of American musical theatre and one of the greatest songwriting duos of all time. The first act ballad entitled "I Miss the Music," sung by the composer character about how he can't write anymore now that his lyricist partner has left him is poignant enough to bring a tear to one's eye. And the second act number "A Tough Act to Follow" is perfectly fitting because it definitely will be. One should see Curtains for a frivolous good time and to pay respects to the end of the Kander-Ebb era.
Curtains is currently playing at the Al Hirschfeld Theater on 45th Street, New York, NY.